The Smut Marathon is an English writing contest for erotica, that has entered the fourth round already. I am very honored to be a jury member for the Smut Marathon. After each voting round, I would like to take you onto a journey in the world of a jury member.
Assignment 4: Write a story about masturbating with a sex toy
The assignment for round 4 was:
Write a hot, erotic masturbation scene where your character uses a sex toy. One character. One sex toy. No brand names.
And the organization also added:
I want sizzling hot stories; stories that will make the readers want to wank!!!
And that story could only have a maximum of 300 words. Of the 39 contestants that survived so far, only 34 send in an entry.
It is very challenging to read so many stories and to provide them with a rating. Especially with an assignment like this one, where it is not about some writing technique. ‘Judging’ these stories can soon become a subjective thing. For this round, I payed attention to the following:
- Has the author kept to the assignment?
- Is the story original?
- Is the text well cared-for (punctuation, empty lines, errors)?
- Is it erotic and arousing?
Tips for writing opening lines
Every writer struggles with the most ideal opening line. And definitely in short stories like in the Smut Marathon, the opening line is crucial. Many beginning authors have the tendency to start with some context: what preceded? Where does the story take place? Who are the personas? Not only do you spoil a lot of words – if you are only allowed to use 300 – it is often also … well, kinda boring.
The goal of an opening line is to make instantly clear where the reader ended up. I always compare it with the opening of a police series; it persistently starts with the crime scene.
So, pay attention to:
- The American play writer Jacob M. Appel once said: ‘Start with the throw of the rock, not with the run up to it’. Leave behind the narrative. Skip the explanation. Start in the middle of the story, in the middle of the action. Or, perhaps even just after the action.
- Don’t start with a personal pronoun. Many stories start with ‘I’, ‘he’, ‘she’ or a name. ‘Julia woke up early that morning’. This seems a great opening line (after all, you now know that Julia is the main character and it is apparently morning), but it is far from original. In this case you could have written ‘The alarm clock did not go and already Julia had woken up’. It gives just as much, or even more, context and it is a more titellating opening.
- Start zoomed in and then zoom out. Start with something small and place that into perspective. A detail can symbolize a setting, a location, or an atmosphere. This way, you immediately have the readers’ attention and you create speed in your story. You can start zoomed out, by for example starting with the description of a street and then go to the bedroom of the main character, but in a short story that may be too thready.
- Make your opening line simple. Avoid clauses, listings and too many punctuation. Has your opening line more than one comma, a semi colon or a colon? Break up your sentence. Compare the next two opening lines:
“I had known Betty for a week. We screwed every night. The forecast was for storms.” [Opening of the movie Betty Blue, 37°2 le matin. OK, it starts with ‘I’, but it is simple and effective.]
“Cheryl’s mind turned like the vanes of a wind-powered turbine, chopping her sparrow-like thoughts into bloody pieces that fell onto a growing pile of forgotten memories.” [Sue Fondrie, winner of the worst opening line of 2011]
- You can start with a dialogue or a quote, but I wouldn’t recommend it. You get a lot of punctuation and it just looks awful. Also, it almost forces you to zoom out and give context to clarify the situation.
A story is not a report
For a couple of entries in this round, my comment was that the stories read like a report. What I meant was that it didn’t comply with the ‘show, don’t tell’ rule.
A number of masturbation stories were like a technical description of the event: ‘First he did this. Then that. And later on also something else’.
Certainly with an erotic story, the reader is interested in what goes on between the ears, rather than between the legs. Even if the setting and the events are very exiting, if you suffice with a description, it often is not. Tell the reader only the things he cannot complete himself. What goes on in someone’s head, describe a scent, a memory. Make sure the reader understands why the main character is so turned on by what is happening.
The entries and my feedback
You can read all the entries for this round here. My feedback on th i ndividual stories is in the comments below the entries. The results of this round can be found here.
Marc van Lier
Latest posts by Marc van Lier (see all)
- Water or silicone based lube? Choose your personal lube in just 3 easy steps - 19 July 2019
- Online adult comics: Baldazzini - 15 July 2019
- Try this role playing game: The servant - 15 July 2019
Thank you again for taking your time to blog about this and help the writers.
Rebel xox
I think the most interesting thing here is that we are not writing against the same criteria you are judging against. Having said that, your comments are completely appropriate, when in context. Thanks for this post.
I can imagine it must be frustrating to see that your entree is judged by other criteria than what is apparent. First of all, my comments are never intended to bring somebody down. They are meant to inspire and make contestants grow as a writer.
As a jury member I first look if a story complies with the assignment. Usually they all do. So the next thing is to see who wrote the best story and then things like an opening line or ‘show, don’t tell’ start to be techniques that distinguishes one story from another. I think it is only fair to share those techniques, so every contestant can improve their entrees.
The further you get in the marathon, the more these techniques will become an important factor, even though they are not explicitly mentioned in the assignment. After all, those are the things that will make your story stand out: punctuation, story line, plot, show/don’t tell, opening line, etc.
I hope you find the comments motivating to keep enjoying the marathon.
Glad I could have been of help. The great thing of the Smut Marathon is that it will allow you to grow as a writer. Looking forward for your next entries.
Thank you, this is some really helpful advice. I definitely entered more of a report than story in the last round, but hopefully this will have been a lesson learnt for the future!
Aurora x